- Kaleb Bass, 58.8% – 2016
- Jon Raney, 56.2% – 2006
- Kaleb Bass, 55.7% – 2017
- Andrew Zender, 53.8% – 2013
- Jon Raney, 53.3% – 2007
- Brent Cowden, 53.1% – 2000
- Mason Bass, 52.6% – 2015
- Tim Knebel, 52.0% – 1983
- Lance Zamzow, 51.1% – 1993
- Andrew Zender, 51.0% – 2012
- Jeff Curtis, 50.0% – 1985
- Ken Gates, 49.5% – 1989
- Tim Knebel, 48.9% – 1984
- Tom Horsmon, 48.5% – 1993
- David Galbraith, 48.3% – 1994
Mason Bass