- Oliver Dougherty, 8 – 2011
- Darice Haywood, 7 – 2012
- Spencer Lee, 7 – 2016
- Steve Jones, 6 – 1980
- Brant Bengen, 6 – 1981
- Matt Zandstra, 6 – 1987
- Ty Elmendorf, 6 – 1990
- Kyle Redmond, 6 – 2012
- Mike Elsner, 5 – 1982
- Brian Langstraat, 5 – 1984
- Eric Swanson, 5 – 1988
- Jason Staeber, 5 – 1988
- Tyler DeFries, 5 – 1995
- Toby Seim, 5 – 2002
- Zach Lorenz, 5 – 2015
- Joseph Worley, 5 – 2016
